To me, this article about an $800 (for one month!) "Detox Cleanse" program only supports the myth that you have to be affluent to eat healthy and exercise. Essentially, what the writer did to lose weight was to substitute healthy food for processed food and sugar (cutting calories at the same time) and to exercise more often than she had been. She lost nine pounds in a month. This might be a little too rapid to maintain if she adds back in some of the draconian cutbacks like chicken and beef. She might regain a few pounds. She didn't say how hard she was working out--"cardio three days a week and yoga or Pilates at least three" as prescribed by the naturopath. Sounds pretty lackluster. Try combining the cardio with weight training for five or ten minutes a day and spend the rest of the time going for a nice walk outside.
What else was included for $800? Counseling from a naturopath, support meetings, all supplements, mandatory saunas, a long list of foods to eliminate, a handbook, a recipe book, two "spa treatments," and unlimited exercise classes including yoga and Pilates. To me, the valuable part is the counseling. I think most people who want to accomplish the grindingly difficult task of losing weight need one-on-one help with specific ideas and role-modeling for making changes in their lives. But if a person can find that kind of support, which would not have to come from a professional, that could be half the battle toward long-lasting positive changes. A person with specific ideas and daily tools like a food diary could eat healthy, exercise, and lose weight without supplements and exercise classes.
Besides the colossal amount of money for this program, at least two other things scream Yuppie Trap: "naturopath" and "supplements." Naturopathic medicine sounds suspiciously vague, and in any case I think a less expensive type of counselor could help just as much. And supplements bug me because they are marketed in two ways that are both dishonest: one, implying that merely eating a healthy diet and exercising isn't good enough, and two, implying that supplements are a shortcut to health and fitness, the magic pill that lets you avoid the hard work. A third Yuppie Trap Flag is the name "detox cleanse." Feel guilty... feel very guilty... if you've been eating Taco Bell you are not only unclean... you might as well have been freebasing!
Search
About this Entry
This page contains a single entry by Fran published on April 5, 2006 12:52 PM.
Handwalking was the previous entry in this blog.
Front Limber Bridge is the next entry in this blog.
Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.
Categories
- "Angie" (1)
- "Chelsea" (2)
- "Christine" (4)
- "Cindy" (2)
- "Fran" (4)
- "Helen" (7)
- "Jackie" (1)
- Boxing Workout (5)
- CrossFit workouts (155)
- Fight Gone Bad (3)
- Fitness Benchmarks (19)
- Fitness Links (10)
- Gymnastics (1)
- Home Workouts (10)
- Hooverball (1)
- Kettlebells (11)
- Outdoor Workouts (9)
- Suffer on Saturday at CF North (6)
- Swimming (1)
- Training (46)
Monthly Archives
- February 2008 (1)
- January 2008 (4)
- December 2007 (5)
- November 2007 (4)
- October 2007 (3)
- September 2007 (3)
- August 2007 (3)
- July 2007 (3)
- June 2007 (2)
- May 2007 (1)
- April 2007 (2)
- March 2007 (4)
- February 2007 (3)
- January 2007 (4)
- December 2006 (2)
- November 2006 (5)
- October 2006 (6)
- September 2006 (1)
- August 2006 (7)
- June 2006 (4)
- May 2006 (4)
- April 2006 (3)
- March 2006 (7)
- January 2006 (5)
- December 2005 (4)
- November 2005 (5)
- October 2005 (6)
- September 2005 (10)
- August 2005 (5)
- July 2005 (5)
- June 2005 (7)
- May 2005 (6)
- April 2005 (8)
- March 2005 (16)
- February 2005 (9)
- January 2005 (17)
- December 2004 (16)
- November 2004 (14)
- October 2004 (5)
- September 2004 (6)
- August 2004 (1)
- July 2004 (3)
- June 2004 (2)
- March 2004 (2)
- February 2004 (1)
- January 2004 (6)
- December 2003 (2)
- November 2003 (2)
- October 2003 (2)
- September 2003 (3)
- August 2003 (6)
- July 2003 (8)